Shipmunks

Lemon Squeezy vs Stripe: what you pay after the shutdown

Blog · No. 053

Processing stops March 31, 2027. On a $29 subscription at $10,000 a month, Managed Payments at 3.5% is $858 and Lemon Squeezy today is $767.

On this page
  1. The short answer
  2. What Lemon Squeezy announced, and the dates
  3. Lemon Squeezy vs Stripe on the same sale
  4. Stripe as processor vs Stripe as merchant of record
  5. The alternatives: Paddle, Dodo Payments, and Creem
  6. What each one costs at $1,000, $10,000, and $50,000 a month
  7. What does not move with you
  8. Which one to pick
  9. FAQ
  10. Sources
  11. Related

The short answer

Lemon Squeezy stops processing on March 31, 2027, including renewals, and extensions will not be offered. Managed Payments adds 3.5% on top of 2.9% + 30¢, or 1.5% through December 1, 2027 if you install the toolkit. On a $29 subscription at $10,000 a month, that is $858 against $767 on Lemon Squeezy today. The lowest merchant of record fee in this math is Creem, then Dodo Payments.

Those two dollar figures are rounded to the nearest dollar, payout included, on a US seller with 30% of revenue outside the US. The fee sits on Money and ops and next to the other formulas on SaaS metrics. The form that produced the months is the payment fee calculator.

What Lemon Squeezy announced, and the dates

The migration guide, checked November 16, 2026, says: “Lemon Squeezy is winding down and will stop processing transactions on March 31, 2027.” The next sentence says every store has to move by then, “and extensions will not be offered.”

The same page recommends Managed Payments, “Stripe’s merchant of record solution for digital goods businesses.” If you are not eligible, or you rely on something Managed Payments does not support, you move to another provider.

The homepage says sign-ups are closed and that existing stores stop processing on March 31, 2027. JR Farr’s post the same day says new store sign-ups are closed and that payments stop on March 31, 2027. He also says the deadline will not be extended.

The four dates on the migration guide, checked November 16, 2026
DateWhat the guide says
November 16, 2026New users and new store sign-ups stop.
December 2, 2026Migration tooling opens at app.lemonsqueezy.com/migration for eligible stores.
Mid-January 2027Latest date they recommend you start. The FAQ says a migration takes 4 to 8 weeks.
March 31, 2027Processing stops, including subscription renewals.

The promo rate is on that same guide. Merchants who migrate get 1.5% on Managed Payments through December 1, 2027. It starts when you install the toolkit, as early as December 2, 2026. Stripe’s payment processing fees still apply. The FAQ says movers may get that 1.5%. This post shows both the 1.5% and the 3.5% on Stripe’s own page, and it does not treat the promo as automatic.

Lemon Squeezy vs Stripe on the same sale

One $29 subscription, paid with a US card, no tax added to the price. This is one charge, not the blended month above. International add-ons are zero. The subscription add-on is on. Payout fees are not in this charge. They show up in the month tables, because a payout is a month, not a sale.

Lemon Squeezy, from the fee docs. 5% of $29 is $1.45. The subscription add-on is 0.5% of $29, which is $0.145. Add the $0.50. The fee is $2.095, which rounds to $2.10. You keep $26.90 before any payout fee.

Stripe Payments, from the pricing page and Billing. 2.9% of $29 is $0.841. Billing at 0.7% is $0.203. Add $0.30. The fee is $1.344, which rounds to $1.34. You keep $27.66. You are the merchant. The sales tax filing is still yours.

Stripe Managed Payments at 3.5%, from the Managed Payments page, on top of those same card and Billing lines. 3.5% of $29 is $1.015. Add the $0.841, the $0.203, and the $0.30. The fee is $2.359, which rounds to $2.36. You keep $26.64. Stripe is the merchant on that charge.

The 1.5% mover rate, if you get it, replaces the 3.5% and leaves the card fee and Billing in place. 1.5% of $29 is $0.435. Add $0.841, $0.203, and $0.30. The fee is $1.779, which rounds to $1.78. You keep $27.22.

On this one domestic charge, Lemon Squeezy at $2.10 is cheaper than Managed Payments at $2.36, and more expensive than the 1.5% promo at $1.78. Stripe Payments at $1.34 is the lowest, and it does not file your tax. The single-sale version of the Lemon Squeezy line, at $6, $35, and $99, is Lemon Squeezy fees.

Creem on this same $29 charge is 3.9% plus $0.40, which is $1.53, before the payout floor. Dodo is 4.5% plus $0.40, which is $1.71, before the $5 payout that applies when a payout is under $1,000. Those floors are month-level. Putting them on one $29 sale makes Creem look like $15.53 and Dodo like $6.71, which is the floor, not the card rate. The month tables are the comparison that includes them once.

Stripe as processor vs Stripe as merchant of record

A processor moves the card charge. You are the seller. Sales tax and VAT attach to you. A merchant of record is the seller on the receipt. They calculate, collect, and remit the indirect tax.

Stripe Payments is the processor. The card rate is 2.9% + 30¢ for a domestic card. An international card adds 1.5%. Currency conversion adds 1%, on the local payment methods page. A card number that was typed in adds 0.5%, and the rows in this post leave that out because they are online charges. Billing, pay as you go, is 0.7% of Billing volume. The Managed Payments page says Billing is a separate product. The subscription rows in this post include the 0.7%. If you are not using Billing, take it out.

Stripe Tax Basic is 0.5% per transaction on the no-code integrations, where you are registered to collect, on the Tax pricing page. The API rate on that page is 50¢ per transaction. The months below leave Tax Basic off. Turning it on adds it to Stripe Payments only. Managed Payments already includes the tax work, so the 0.5% is not added there.

Managed Payments adds 3.5% per successful transaction on top of Payments fees. Stripe, through Link, is the merchant of record. The page lists indirect tax, fraud, disputes, and transaction support inside that 3.5%. Adaptive Pricing is on by default in the docs, and the customer sees the converted price. This math does not add the 1% conversion line on Managed Payments. Stripe’s payout docs say Stripe does not charge a fee to start a normal payout. Instant Payouts on the pricing page are 1.5%, and they are not in these rows.

A dispute on Stripe Payments is $15 when it arrives, and another $15 if you counter it yourself. The counter fee comes back if you win. On Managed Payments, Stripe handles the dispute and covers the evidence fee when Stripe submits the evidence. If you counter it yourself, the evidence fee applies.

Stripe Payments is the lowest fee because you are the merchant of record. You register, file, and remit sales tax and VAT yourself, and you handle disputes. Managed Payments costs more because Stripe takes that job. The two rows are not substitutes.

The alternatives: Paddle, Dodo Payments, and Creem

Paddle is a merchant of record at 5% + 50¢ per checkout transaction. Products under $10 are “bespoke pricing,” and the page does not print it. A chargeback is $20 on a USD charge, and the help center says the fee is not refunded if Paddle wins. Local payouts are free. A SWIFT transfer is $15 when the payout currency does not match the bank’s country. The pricing page does not print an FX margin. The terms reserve a conversion margin of up to 1.5% if you are paid in a different currency from the payment currency. The calculator adds neither. Check your contract.

Dodo Payments is a merchant of record at 4% + 40¢ on US cards and wallets. Cards outside the US add 1.5%. Subscriptions add 0.5%. PayPal and Buy Now Pay Later add 3%. A refund is $1, and that $1 is not in the month tables. A dispute is $30. Standard payouts are free, and a payout under $1,000 costs $5. The page does not say how often payouts run, so the calculator uses one a month and labels it. USD SWIFT for a business outside the US is $25. Adaptive currency on that page charges the customer 2% to 4% and charges you 0%. The rows do not add a second FX line.

Creem is a merchant of record at 3.9% + 40¢. The page says there are no international card fees. It does not list PayPal. A chargeback is $25 on the refunds page. Payouts run on the 1st and the 15th. Each bank payout is the higher of $7 or 1% of the amount. The month tables assume you take both, and that the month’s net splits in half. Affiliates add 2% on the payout docs, and only when the sale goes through that program. The rows leave the 2% out.

Lemon Squeezy and Creem both take the percent on the tax-inclusive total. Creem’s France example is a $20 product, $4 of VAT, a $24 total, and a platform fee of $1.33. The calculator and these tables use the pre-tax price. A sticker that already contains tax costs more than the row.

What a Lemon Squeezy store does not get to carry over is the other half of the choice. The FAQ says Managed Payments has no PayPal, no license keys, no file hosting, and no affiliates. Stripe does not support product variants, so each variant becomes its own product. Country eligibility is limited to supported business locations, and the pages checked here do not print the country list. Only card subscriptions can move to another provider. PayPal subscribers have to buy again.

What each one costs at $1,000, $10,000, and $50,000 a month

These months are the original arithmetic behind the post. Same switches as the calculator’s defaults: US seller, 30% of revenue outside the US, conversion percent equal to that 30% for Stripe Payments only, subscription on, PayPal at 0%, Stripe Tax off. Fees include the payout assumption and are rounded to the nearest dollar. The cent, and any other mix, is the payment fee calculator. The sheet of the same months is on that page.

Rows in each table follow the $10,000 column. At $1,000 and a $29 charge, the 1.5% Managed Payments row is $66 and Creem is $67, so the $1,000 order is not the $10,000 order. At $1,000 and a $99 charge, Paddle is $55, under Creem at $57, and the 1.5% row and Dodo both round to $59.

$29 average charge. US seller, 30% outside the US, subscription, no PayPal. Rounded to the nearest dollar.
Provider$1,000$10,000$50,000
Stripe Payments$54$538$2,692
Creem$67$623$3,113
Dodo Payments$68$633$3,165
Managed Payments, 1.5%$66$658$3,292
Paddle$67$672$3,362
Lemon Squeezy$77$767$3,837
Managed Payments, 3.5%$86$858$4,292

The $10,000 row at $29 is the short answer. Stripe Payments is $538, which is 5.4%. Creem is $623. Dodo is $633. The 1.5% promo is $658. Paddle is $672. Lemon Squeezy is $767. Managed Payments at 3.5% is $858. Creem’s payout on that month is about 1% of net, because 1% of each half is above the $7 floor. At $1,000 the floor binds, and Creem’s payout is $14 on top of the card fee. That is why Creem and Paddle both round to $67 at $1,000, and Creem pulls ahead once the month is larger.

$9 average charge. The fixed fee per charge is most of the gap. Paddle’s public rate, not a bespoke deal.
Provider$1,000$10,000$50,000
Stripe Payments$77$768$3,842
Managed Payments, 1.5%$89$888$4,442
Creem$97$926$4,631
Dodo Payments$99$939$4,697
Paddle$106$1,056$5,278
Managed Payments, 3.5%$109$1,088$5,442
Lemon Squeezy$115$1,151$5,753
$99 average charge. Fewer charges, so the fixed fee matters less.
Provider$1,000$10,000$50,000
Stripe Payments$47$465$2,327
Creem$57$526$2,631
Dodo Payments$59$535$2,677
Paddle$55$551$2,753
Managed Payments, 1.5%$59$585$2,927
Lemon Squeezy$65$646$3,228
Managed Payments, 3.5%$79$785$3,927

Take the fee out before you call the remainder margin. What belongs in that cost, and what does not, is SaaS gross margin. The $10,000 is not MRR until it is the monthly price of subscriptions you still have. That count is the MRR calculator.

Payment fee calculator The same rates, with the international share, PayPal, subscription, tax, and seller location as fields. State stays in the URL. Free tool

What does not move with you

The FAQ is specific about the gaps. Read it against your own store before you pick a row for the price.

PayPal subscriptions cannot migrate. The customer has to start a new subscription on a method Managed Payments supports. If you leave for a provider that is not Stripe, only card subscriptions are eligible to move. Cash App Pay can move to Managed Payments and cannot move to another provider. Some cards, including India-issued cards, have to be authorized again.

License keys, file hosting, and download links are not on Managed Payments. Affiliates are not on it either. The FAQ points at a separate affiliate tool. Variants become separate products. Checkout links, storefront URLs, embeds, API endpoints, and webhooks do not redirect. You replace them.

Eligibility depends on where the business is based. A store in an unsupported country does not move to Managed Payments. The pages checked on November 16, 2026 do not print the country list. If you are outside it, the guide says you export your data and move somewhere else before March 31, 2027.

A renewal that fails during the move is still a failed payment. The note for that, and what Stripe and Lemon Squeezy already retry, is the dunning email. People who cancel are not a fee. They are churn.

Which one to pick

No row here is a recommendation for a company this page has not seen. The table is the situation, then the row the math and the docs point at. Prices were checked November 16, 2026. A pricing page can change. Open it again before you move.

Which published row matches the constraint. Not a ranking of companies.
SituationWhat the pages support
You will register and file sales tax and VAT yourselfStripe Payments. It is the lowest fee because you are the merchant of record.
You want Stripe to be the merchant of recordManaged Payments at 3.5% on top of Payments fees. Billing at 0.7% is separate. These subscription rows include it.
You can install the Lemon Squeezy migration toolkitThe guide says 1.5% through December 1, 2027, from the day you install it. The FAQ says you may get that rate. Recheck it before December 1, 2027.
PayPal subscribers have to come with youNot Managed Payments. They have to buy again. Dodo lists PayPal at an extra 3%.
You need license keys or file delivery in the same productNot Managed Payments. Dodo’s pricing page includes license keys and digital delivery. Confirm the current list on that page.
You use affiliates inside the checkoutManaged Payments does not include them. Creem adds 2% when a sale uses its affiliate program.
The average charge is under $10Paddle and Lemon Squeezy both say to ask. The public rate is what these rows use.
You want the lowest merchant of record fee in this mathCreem, then Dodo Payments, on the default mix at $10,000 and a $29 charge. Change the switches and run the form. The order is not a law.
Lemon Squeezy fees: what you keep on a sale 5% + 50¢, then the international, PayPal, and subscription add-ons, at $6, $35, and $99. Guide

FAQ

Is Lemon Squeezy shutting down?

Yes. The migration guide says Lemon Squeezy is winding down and will stop processing transactions on March 31, 2027, and that extensions will not be offered. New users and new stores closed on November 16, 2026. Existing stores can keep charging until the stop date. Checked November 16, 2026.

When does Lemon Squeezy stop processing?

March 31, 2027, including subscription renewals. The FAQ says a migration takes 4 to 8 weeks, and that the March 31 deadline will not be extended. The guide says to start no later than mid-January 2027.

Is Stripe a merchant of record?

Stripe Payments is not. You are the merchant, and you file sales tax and VAT. Stripe Managed Payments is. Stripe, through Link, is the seller on those charges and handles indirect tax in the countries it supports. The two products are on the same company and they are not the same job.

What is the Lemon Squeezy migration promo rate?

The migration guide says merchants who move to Managed Payments get 1.5% through December 1, 2027, starting when they install the migration toolkit, as early as December 2, 2026. Stripe’s card fees still apply. The FAQ says movers may get that rate. The standard Managed Payments rate on Stripe’s page is 3.5% on top of Payments fees.

Does Stripe Managed Payments support PayPal?

No. The migration FAQ says PayPal is not supported. A PayPal subscription cannot move as a PayPal subscription. The customer has to buy again with a supported payment method. Cash App Pay can move to Managed Payments, and it cannot move to another provider.

Is Paddle cheaper than Lemon Squeezy?

On the default month in this post, yes. US seller, 30% of revenue outside the US, a subscription, no PayPal, payout included. At $10,000 and a $29 charge, Paddle is $672 and Lemon Squeezy is $767, both rounded to the nearest dollar. Paddle’s pricing page says to ask for a custom rate under $10, and that rate is not printed. The $9 rows use the public 5% + 50¢.

Sources

  1. Migration: Lemon Squeezy is winding down Checked
  2. Lemon Squeezy wind-down FAQs Checked
  3. Saying goodbye to Lemon Squeezy (JR Farr) Checked
  4. Lemon Squeezy homepage Checked
  5. Pricing (Lemon Squeezy) Checked
  6. Fees (Lemon Squeezy docs) Checked
  7. Refunds and chargebacks (Lemon Squeezy docs) Checked
  8. Pricing and fees (Stripe) Checked
  9. Local payment method pricing (Stripe) Checked
  10. Billing pricing (Stripe) Checked
  11. Stripe Tax pricing Checked
  12. Payouts (Stripe docs) Checked
  13. Managed Payments (Stripe) Checked
  14. How Managed Payments works (Stripe docs) Checked
  15. Pricing (Paddle) Checked
  16. Understanding chargebacks (Paddle) Checked
  17. Is there a fee taken for payouts? (Paddle) Checked
  18. Master services agreement (Paddle) Checked
  19. Pricing (Dodo Payments) Checked
  20. Pricing (Creem) Checked
  21. Payouts (Creem docs) Checked
  22. Refunds and chargebacks (Creem docs) Checked